How to choose an SR&ED consultant

A good SR&ED consultant finds the work that qualifies, writes a technical narrative that matches how the Canada Revenue Agency reviews claims, and stands behind the claim if it is reviewed. Before you sign, ask who writes the report, how the fee is set, what records they need from your team and what happens in a review. For a Canadian-controlled private corporation, the enhanced credit applies to qualified spending up to a maximum expenditure limit of $6 million a year, so a well documented claim is worth more than a quick one.

Chase Miller

Co-Founder, published this page

Facts checked against the official source

average funding secured per client
$334,132
approval rate
94%

What an SR&ED consultant does

The program pays a tax credit on qualified research and experimental development work, but the money depends on the claim. A consultant's job is to find the technical uncertainty in your projects, show the systematic work your team did to resolve it, and tie the right salaries, contractor costs and materials to that work. Most of the value sits in the technical narrative and the cost allocation, not in filling in the form.

A strong consultant also tells you what does not qualify. Routine engineering, cosmetic changes and work with no real uncertainty weaken a claim and invite questions. Expect them to interview your technical leads, read your project records and push back when the evidence is thin. If a firm promises a number before it has seen your work, treat that as a warning, not a selling point.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • Who writes the technical narrative, and do they have a science or engineering background in your field?
  • Will the person who writes the claim also defend it if the Canada Revenue Agency asks questions?
  • How is the fee calculated, and what is the fee if the claim is reduced on review?
  • What records do you need from us, and how much of our engineers' time will the claim take?
  • How do you decide which projects and costs to leave out?
  • Do you review our other funding, such as grants or contributions, that can reduce the eligible costs?
  • Can we read a sample technical narrative with client details removed?

Clear, specific answers to these questions tell you more than a fee quote does.

How consultants charge

Most firms use one of three models. A contingency fee is a share of the credit you receive: you pay nothing up front, but the fee grows with the claim and can be large on a big refund. A fixed fee is agreed before the work starts: it is predictable and does not reward an inflated claim, but you pay it even if the claim is small. Hourly billing suits companies that do most of the work in house and want a specialist to review it.

Whatever the model, read what happens when a claim is reviewed. Ask whether review support is included or billed separately, whether the fee is recalculated if the credit is reduced, and whether you owe anything for a claim you decide not to file. A low headline rate with paid review support can cost more than a higher rate that includes it.

Who writes the technical report

The technical narrative is the heart of the claim. It has to show a technological uncertainty, the hypotheses your team tested, the systematic investigation you carried out and the advancement you were seeking, in language a reviewer with a technical background will accept. A generic narrative that could describe any company is the most common reason a claim gets questioned.

Ask who drafts it and how they gather the facts. The best narratives come from interviews with the people who did the work, backed by the records they kept as they went: commit history, test results, design notes and meeting notes. If a firm drafts the report from a short questionnaire and has a junior writer fill in the gaps, the claim may read well and still fail to hold up.

Support if your claim is reviewed

The Canada Revenue Agency can review any claim, and a review can cover the science, the costs or both. A good consultant prepares you before it happens: they keep the evidence behind every project in one place, brief your technical leads on what the reviewer will ask, and attend the meetings with you.

Ask the firm to describe its last few reviews in plain terms: who attended, how long it took and what changed. Ask whether review support is in writing in the engagement letter. A consultant who files the claim and then disappears leaves your engineers to defend work they did not write up. That is the moment a cheaper firm becomes the expensive one.

Check the size of the claim first

For a Canadian-controlled private corporation, the enhanced refundable credit applies to qualified spending up to a maximum expenditure limit of $6 million a year. That limit shrinks for larger companies: it begins to decrease when taxable capital employed in Canada for the previous tax year reaches $15 million and becomes nil at $75 million.

Know roughly where your company sits before you talk to a consultant. If your qualified spending is modest, a fixed fee usually costs less than a contingency fee. If you are close to the limit or your taxable capital is near the point where it starts to shrink, ask the consultant to show how they calculated the claim. The rules are on the Canada Revenue Agency's investment tax credit page.

Red flags

  • A refund amount quoted before anyone has looked at your projects.
  • A narrative written from a questionnaire with no interview of your technical team.
  • Review support that is vague, missing from the engagement letter or billed by the hour.
  • Pressure to include routine work, such as bug fixing or standard integrations, to make the claim bigger.
  • No question about the grants or other government funding you received for the same work.

Any one of these is worth a direct question. Two or more is a reason to keep looking. Read our overview of the program for how the credit works before your first call with any firm.

Questions

Do I need a consultant to make an SR&ED claim?

No. Many companies file their own claims, and the Canada Revenue Agency publishes its guidance for free. A consultant is worth it when your team lacks the time or experience to write a strong technical narrative and defend it in a review.

Is a contingency fee or a fixed fee better?

A contingency fee costs nothing up front but grows with the claim; a fixed fee is predictable and does not reward an inflated claim. Compare the total you would pay on your expected claim, including review support, rather than the headline rate.

What should a consultant need from my team?

Interviews with the people who did the technical work and the records they kept: project plans, test results, code history and timesheets. A firm that needs almost nothing from you is likely writing a generic claim.

What happens if the Canada Revenue Agency reviews my claim?

A reviewer may ask about the science, the costs or both, and can meet with your technical team. Choose a consultant who puts review support in writing and attends those meetings with you.

Your next step

Book a free call